Denny McCarthy

Denny McCarthy

33-Year-Old Golfer
https://content.rotowire.com/images/flags/USA.png
2025 Fantasy Outlook
McCarthy was known as a solid golfer and a great putter up through the 2022 season, but his 2023 season changed everything. During that season he scored eight top-10s on his way to over $6 million in earnings. Essentially, he reset the bar, a bar which he's failed to reach the past two seasons. It's only through the eyes of raised expectations that McCarthy has underperformed though, as he's come close to hitting the $4 million mark in each of those campaigns and landed in the top 50 after each. McCarthy is not a splashy player, he's very much the opposite. He's as consistent as they come finishing inside the top-25 in nearly half of his starts since 2023. While he has yet to win, if he keeps up this pace, he's bound to find a win at some point. As such, McCarthy should be considered in salary cap leagues this season. Read Past Outlooks
Share of 47th at The Genesis
February 23, 2026
McCarthy posted an even-par cumulative score at The Genesis Invitational and finished tied with Andrew Novak for 47th.
ANALYSIS
McCarthy failed to score under 70 across all four rounds. He finished in the top-25 in SG: Around-the-Green, SG: Putting and GIR. However, he lost 3.3 strokes off the tee and 3.5 strokes with his irons, ranking 49th and 44th in SG: Off-the-Tee and SG: Approach-to-Green, respectively. McCarthy has made the cut in all five of his PGA Tour appearances in 2026, though he's finished T40 or worse in each of those events. He won't participate in next week's Cognizant Classic as he gears up for the Arnold Palmer Invitational that tees off March 5. McCarthy has made the cut in four of five outings at the API, with his solo 18th in 2025 being his best performance.
Read More News
PGA Stats
Loading Golf Stats...
Tournament Results
Scoring
FanDuel
DraftKings
Loading Tournament Log...
PGA Advanced Stats
Loading Advanced Stats...
Projected PGA Tournament Status
Loading Tournaments...
Recent RotoWire Articles Featuring Denny McCarthy See More
Weekly Fantasy Golf Preview: Arnold Palmer Invitational
8 days ago
Your full fantasy golf preview for the Arnold Palmer Invitational, including why Greg Vara likes the value Keegan Bradley brings in multiple formats this week at Bay Hill.
Weekly Fantasy Golf Preview: Cognizant Classic in The Palm Beaches
15 days ago
Your full fantasy golf preview for the Cognizant Classic in The Palm Beaches, including Greg Vara's best bets, DFS values and OAD strategy this week at PGA National.
Weekly Fantasy Golf Preview: The Genesis Invitational
22 days ago
Your full fantasy golf preview for The Genesis Invitational, including Greg Vara's best bets, DFS values and one and done strategy this week at Riviera.
2026 AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am Betting: Picks, Odds, Predictions and Best Bets
28 days ago
The best bets and picks for the AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am, including why Ryan Pohle is high on Taylor Pendrith's chances to score a top-5 finish this week.
Weekly Fantasy Golf Preview: AT&T Pebble Beach Pro Am
29 days ago
Your full fantasy golf preview for the AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am, including Greg Vara's best bets, DFS values and OAD plays this week.
Past Fantasy Outlooks
2024
2023
2022
2020
2019
2018
2017
It would have been hard to imagine a player who historically depended so heavily on putting having such a consistent season. Yet, McCarthy made significant improvements in all aspects of his game in 2022-23. He gained strokes in every category, ranking ninth in scrambling and third in SG: Putting. This translated into a remarkable record of 24 cuts made out of 30 starts, with an impressive number of top-25 finishes. At 30 years old, McCarthy may not become a top-tier ball-striker, but with his strong short game and putting skills, he doesn't need to be. Seeing McCarthy clinch his first PGA Tour win in 2024 would certainly not be a surprise.
McCarthy started as a rookie on the PGA Tour during the 2017-2018 and his results were less than desired as he finished the season ranked 149th on the FedEx list. In the three seasons that followed, McCarthy showed some progress, but it was slow. That changed this past season when McCarthy posted career highs in cuts made, top-25s, top-10s and earnings. McCarthy has never lived off the high-end finishes, so the fact that he took the slow and steady route to a career high in earnings this past is not surprise either. McCarthy will need to find some high-end finishes to improve upon his number this season, but he appears capable at this point. As such, he makes for an intersting salary cap selection this season.
McCarthy went from missing just five cuts in 2019-20, to missing 13 cuts in 2020-21. He also saw both his top-10s and top-25s go down. McCarthy had another good season with the putter, but his ball-striking numbers need to be better if he is going to amount to anything in salary cap formats.
Amazingly, McCarthy led the Tour in SG: Putting for a second consecutive season but his tee-to-green game leaves much to be desired. He's best viewed as a cut maker who struggles in stronger-field events, but will occasionally contend when he's able to have a good week with his long-game. A safe bet to make the FedEx Cup Playoffs and a contender to win a weaker field event.
McCarthy was a rookie in 2018 and while he wasn't able to retain his card for this past season, he played well enough to earn partial privileges. He parlayed his partial status into 27 starts last season, which resulted in enough points to earn full status for this upcoming season. McCarthy seems to be getting incrementally better, but the progress is slow. He has only three top-10s in 49 starts on the PGA Tour. It's a little too early to take a chance on McCarthy as a salary cap option this season.
McCarthy's rookie season was characterized by a single top-10 and just 13-of-22 made cuts. Denny's driving is PGA Tour average and his putting is great, but his iron game is incredibly underdeveloped. After earning full PGA Tour status by winning the Web.com Tour Championship and overall Web.com Tour Finals, he'll need to maintain his momentum to outpace last year's weak rookie campaign. As a fringe talent, don't expect anything special from McCarthy in the 2018-19 season, but there's a chance he'll ride his current momentum to some solid finishes in the fall season.
Earning a PGA Tour card via the Web.com Tour Finals, McCarthy is set to become a rookie at the next level after making 18 of 23 cuts on the Web.com during 2017. He failed to record any top-three finishes through two seasons on the Web.com Tour, however, so McCarthy's upside may remain limited. McCarthy ranked second in putting average and 21st in birdie average this past season, but was just 128th in terms of GIR percentage.
More Fantasy News
Slow start to 2026
February 16, 2026
McCarthy posted a seven-under cumulative score at the AT&T Pebble Beach Pro-Am to finish tied with Cameron Young and Sam Stevens for 55th.
ANALYSIS
Subscribe now to instantly reveal our take on this news.
Ties for 56th at The AmEx
January 26, 2026
McCarthy closed with a three-under 69 on Sunday at The American Express to finish 14-under and tied for 56th.
ANALYSIS
Subscribe now to instantly reveal our take on this news.
T40 finish at Waialae
January 19, 2026
McCarthy finished in a share of 40th place at the Sony Open in Hawaii following his three-under 67 in the final round.
ANALYSIS
Subscribe now to instantly reveal our take on this news.
Surges with Sunday 63
August 4, 2025
McCarthy fired a final round seven-under 63 at the Wyndham Championship to finish in a share of 11th place.
ANALYSIS
Subscribe now to instantly reveal our take on this news.
T11 at John Deere Classic
July 9, 2025
McCarthy posted a final round six-under 65 on Sunday at the John Deere Classic to finish 15-under par and in a tie for 11th.
ANALYSIS
Subscribe now to instantly reveal our take on this news.