Top MLB Betting Picks for September 17

Top MLB Betting Picks for September 17

This article is part of our MLB Picks series.

Top MLB Betting Picks for September 17: Expert Predictions and Best Bets

Previous article 2-3  ( -1.09 units)  

Season 134-141-2 (-11.14 units)

Cash in on the best sportsbook promos available at the best MLB betting sites this baseball season. The BetMGM bonus code gets new players one of the best welcome bonuses in the industry.

Key MLB Betting Trends and Matchups Analysis

Before locking in your MLB bets Wednesday, be sure to check out these key betting numbers.

As teams fall out of the playoff race, we will start to see inflated moneylines.

Road Favorites - Yankees -165 at Twins, Marlins -160 at Rockies, Cubs -150 at Pirates

Home Favorites -  Brewers -190 vs Angels, Red Sox -170 vs Athletics

Totals - Marlins/Rockies 10.5, Brewers/Angels 7.5, Mets/Padres 7.5

Line Movement - Guardians -16, Athletics -15

Check out Caesars' MLB offerings this season using the Caesars Sportsbook promo code at signup for a generous welcome offer.

San Diego Padres vs New York Mets Best Bets and Predictions

I was on the wrong side of this matchup Tuesday backing the Padres, and the Mets easily won 8-3. But, I am not buying the Mets in any fashion, and I think they will end up missing the playoffs. 

Mets LHP David Peterson has not been in good form over his last seven starts with a 7.13 ERA. Padres RHP Nick Pivetta has been solid all season, with a nearly identical ERA in his last seven versus season long (2.73 ERA). Pivetta has benefited from Petco Park supressing flyballs, and you need to be careful taking him on the road. But, Citi Field is a strong pitchers' park, which helps Pivetta in this spot. 

The Mets are just 2-8 in the previous 10 contests, and 8-12 in the last 20 outings. This team has been on a downward trend for several months and we got the Padres at a good price on the road here. 

Best Bet: Padres ML for 1 unit (-104 at FanDuel Sportsbook)

Check in on one of the top sports betting apps when you sign up with the bet365 bonus code for your baseball betting.

Toronto Blue Jays vs Tampa Bay Rays Best Bets and Predictions

This Blue Jays team has been a machine since June, and they just do not go into any prolonged slumps.  They are 7-3 in the last 10 games, and13-7 in the past 20 outings, while the Rays are just 2-8 in their last 10 showings. 

The Rays have very little motivation, while the Jays are gunning for the first seed in the American League. RHP Kevin Gausman has been on fire across his past seven starts, posting a stellar 2.02 ERA. 

I think we get the Jays at a great price considering where these teams are, both currently, and over the course of the season.

Best Bet: Blue Jays ML for 1 unit (-125 at Caesars Sportsbook) 

Sports betting is officially live in the state of Massachusetts. To get the most bang for your buck when selecting a sportsbook as a new customer, check out these Massachusetts Sports Betting Promos.

Seattle Mariners vs Kansas City Royals Best Bets and Predictions

Royals LHP Cole Ragans is coming back from injury for his first start since June 5th, and I would expect he will have a short leash. We can take advantage of this because I think this line is inflated significantly towards the Royals based on Ragans' name value.

The Mariners have won 10 in a row, although RHP Bryce Miller has struggled on the road much like most of the Seattle pitchers. I am a fan of riding streaks, though, and 10 games is a lot. Chances are it is due for a loss, but the key here is Ragans probably not going very long into this game. 

The Royals were flirting with a potential AL Wild Card spot, but that has faded, leaving them very little motivation. The Mariners are down in first place in the AL West, and home-field is a huge edge for them come playoff time. 

Best Bet: Mariners ML for 1 unit (-102 at FanDuel Sportsbook)

Sports betting is officially live in the state of Massachusetts. To get the most bang for your buck when selecting a sportsbook as a new customer, check out these Massachusetts Sports Betting Promos.

Wednesday's MLB Best Bets

  • Padres ML for 1 unit (-104 at FanDuel Sportsbook)
  • Blue Jays ML for 1 unit (-125 at Caesars Sportsbook) 
  • Mariners ML for 1 unit (-102 at FanDuel Sportsbook)

RotoWire Community
Join Our Subscriber-Only MLB Chat
Chat with our writers and other RotoWire MLB fans for all the pre-game info and in-game banter.
Join The Discussion
ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Michael Rathburn
Known as “Rath” in the Daily Fantasy Sports (DFS) community, he has helped run operations for two prominent daily fantasy sports startups. Michael has taken his insider knowledge and expertise in daily fantasy sports to the content side. Rath won the 2016 FSWA "Baseball Article of the Year, Online" award and was a finalist for the FSWA Best Baseball Series in 2011.
Leaderboard of the Week: Stolen Base Decliners
Leaderboard of the Week: Stolen Base Decliners
Offseason Deep Dives: Noah Cameron
Offseason Deep Dives: Noah Cameron
Collette Calls: Closer Carousel In Full Swing
Collette Calls: Closer Carousel In Full Swing
Which Teams Have The Best Odds For The 2026 MLB World Series?
Which Teams Have The Best Odds For The 2026 MLB World Series?
Offseason Deep Dives: Quinn Priester
Offseason Deep Dives: Quinn Priester
RotoWire Roundtable: 2026 Fantasy Baseball Top-300 Rankings
RotoWire Roundtable: 2026 Fantasy Baseball Top-300 Rankings